Bo Bichette’s Slow Start in New York Raises Questions Despite Strong History vs. Mets

Bo Bichette’s transition to the New York

Mets hasn’t started the way many expected. After signing a three-year deal in the offseason, the former Toronto Blue Jays star has stumbled out of the gate early in the 2026 campaign.

Through his first three games with the Mets, Bichette has managed just one hit in 14 at-bats while striking out eight times. It’s an uncharacteristic stretch for a player known for his consistent bat-to-ball skills and ability to produce offensively in high-pressure situations.

While early-season struggles are nothing new in baseball, the numbers have caught attention given Bichette’s track record. During his time in Toronto, he built a reputation as one of the league’s more reliable hitters, often serving as a key contributor in the heart of the lineup.

What makes this slow start even more intriguing is Bichette’s past success against the very team he now plays for. Before joining the Mets, he had consistently performed well against them, posting a .283 batting average over 11 games. In that span, he collected 13 hits, drove in five runs, and added a home run, proving to be a tough out whenever he faced New York pitching.

Now on the other side, Bichette is adjusting to new surroundings, new teammates, and new expectations. Transitions like this can sometimes take time, even for elite players. The pressure of a fresh contract and a new fanbase can also play a role in early performances.

For the Mets, patience will be key. Bichette’s talent and track record suggest that this is more of a temporary slump than a long-term concern. A player of his caliber is more than capable of turning things around quickly with just a few strong games.

Meanwhile, Blue Jays fans watching from afar may find the situation both surprising and familiar. Baseball is a game of adjustments, and even the best hitters can go through brief cold stretches. The real story will be how Bichette responds moving forward.

As the 2026 season continues, all eyes will be on whether Bichette can rediscover his rhythm and begin to deliver the production the Mets were expecting when they brought him in. If history is any indication, it may only be a matter of time before he does.